I did I trade for my Pin 74316 (DisneyStore.com - Jack in the Box Series - Jack Skellington). He double checked the pin and said he was sure it was real. It came today. Totally matte finish with dips in the enamel. I am SO bummed. I sent off an email asking to trade back. We'll see what happens.
Anyone have a real one they'd be willing to trade me? My pinpics id is: nettiejeanne.